Internal Control · 2024
In this section8 topics
- Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System1 item
- Internal Control Deficiencies1 item
- Audit Committee & Auditor Observations4 items
- Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Related Party Transactions1 item
- Counterparties & Transactions3 items
- Policy & Future Trends2 items
Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System
Internal Control Framework Used
| Framework | Detail |
|---|---|
| The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) | The Board of Directors of the company and its subsidiaries places continuous importance on internal control. The focus is on having an internal control system that is comprehensive, adequate, and appropriate for the business operations to enhance operational efficiency and effectiveness. The internal control system is evaluated at least annually. The Board of Directors has assigned the Audit Committee to oversee the internal control system, risk management system, and corporate governance system of the company to ensure their adequacy and effectiveness. This includes ensuring that the company complies with relevant regulations and laws, overseeing related party transactions to prevent conflicts of interest, and preventing fraud or misconduct. An internal audit department, independent of management, is responsible for reviewing the operations of various departments within the company and its subsidiaries. The results of the audit are reported directly to the Audit Committee to enhance the effectiveness of the company's and its subsidiaries' internal control systems. The company and its subsidiaries have an internal control and risk management system that adopts the framework of the COSO (The Committee Of Sponsoring Organizations Of The Treadway Commission) Internal Control - Integrated Framework, the Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) framework, and the corporate governance principles of the Stock Exchange of Thailand and the Thai Institute of Directors Association (IOD) to ensure the most effective and efficient control. The audit unit, which includes the internal audit unit, is responsible for auditing and reviewing various operating systems and reports directly to the Audit Committee. This ensures operational efficiency and effectiveness, cost-effective use of company resources, and control over operations. It also ensures accurate, complete, reliable, and timely financial reporting and compliance with company regulations, policies, and legal and regulatory requirements of relevant government agencies. The effectiveness of the internal control system is regularly reviewed to ensure that operations are in line with the objectives and maximize benefits in a constantly changing environment, based on fairness to the interests of all stakeholders. In assessing the internal control system across 5 elements, namely, control environment, risk assessment, control activities, information and communication systems, and monitoring activities, the Audit Committee is of the view that the internal control system is adequate and appropriate. The company has allocated sufficient personnel to effectively implement the system, including appropriate and rigorous internal control systems for monitoring and overseeing the operations of subsidiaries and transactions with potentially conflicting and related parties. Furthermore, in conducting the audit of the company's and its subsidiaries' financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2024, in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards, the auditors exercised professional judgment and skepticism throughout the audit process. This included identifying and assessing the risks of material misstatement of the financial statements, whether due to fraud or error; designing and performing audit procedures in response to those risks; and obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence to provide a basis for the auditors' opinion. Based on the auditors' work, the auditors expressed an unqualified opinion on the financial statements. |
| COSO - Enterprise Risk Management Framework (ERM) | The organization has clearly defined objectives to identify and assess various risks associated with achieving organizational goals. It places importance on risk management by establishing a risk management committee and risk management policies at both the organizational and operational levels under the supervision of the Enterprise Risk Management Committee and the coordination of the risk management function. It sets clear objectives for risk assessment, which are risks that may arise from the nature of the organization's work or activities that the existing internal control system does not cover or cannot prevent errors from operations, including non-compliance with the established internal control system. The causes of risk may arise from internal and/or external factors. For accounting operations, there are clearly defined objectives and procedures to ensure that financial reporting is in accordance with financial reporting standards, covering all three objectives of internal control: operations, reporting, and compliance with relevant laws and regulations. The Board of Directors has assigned the Audit Committee to screen the organization's Enterprise Risk Management Framework, which includes Risk Appetite, Risk Capacity, Tolerance, and overall risk management guidelines, as well as reviewing the adequacy of the risk management policy set by the Risk Management Committee before presenting it to the Board of Directors. It is also responsible for screening and advising the Board of Directors on overall risk oversight and assessing the appropriateness of taking risks strategically. |
Internal Control Deficiencies
Number of Deficiencies
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Audit Committee & Auditor Observations
Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's
Yes
Audit Committee's Differing Opinion
At the Board of Directors Meeting No. 1/2024 held on February 28, 2024, which all three Audit Committee members attended, an assessment of the internal control system of the Company and its subsidiaries was conducted. After inquiring about information from management, it was concluded that the assessment of the internal control system of the Company and its subsidiaries in various areas, covering 5 elements, is as follows:
1. Control Environment
1.1 The organization demonstrates a commitment to the values of integrity and ethics. The Board of Directors has established a corporate governance policy, a business ethics policy, and an anti-corruption policy to ensure that directors, executives, and employees at all levels adhere to morality, ethics, honesty, accountability, and conduct business with transparency and integrity in accordance with the law. The company upholds the shared benefits of customers, communities, society, and the environment. All executives operate in accordance with good corporate governance policies and other policies established by the company, setting a good example and adhering to the guidelines or practices stipulated in the company's Code of Ethics and other relevant operational manuals. Internal communication is used to inform personnel and ensure continuous and consistent compliance. Senior executives demonstrate their commitment by declaring a No Gift Policy during the New Year festival to ensure that the company operates appropriately and in line with the anti-corruption policy. The company also adheres to the Principles of Good Corporate Governance for Listed Companies 2017 by establishing guidelines on conflicts of interest, providing channels for reporting corruption, and regularly reviewing corporate governance policies.
1.2 The Board of Directors is independent from management and is responsible for overseeing and developing internal control. The roles and responsibilities of the Board of Directors are clearly separate from management. The Board of Directors consists of more than 50% independent directors with diverse qualifications, knowledge, abilities, and experience beneficial to the company, and who meet the qualifications of the SEC. The Board has established policies and operational plans that align with national strategies, legal frameworks and regulations, regulatory bodies, and shareholder resolutions to ensure effective and efficient corporate governance. The Board has appointed an Audit Committee, a Nomination and Remuneration Committee, a Corporate Governance Committee, and a Risk Management and Sustainability Development Committee to oversee various aspects of management in accordance with established policies and report to the Board of Directors every quarter.
1.3 The Board of Directors and the Executive Committee have established a clear and appropriate reporting structure, authority, and responsibilities to enable the organization to achieve its objectives under the supervision of the Board of Directors. The management structure is regularly reviewed and improved. The roles, responsibilities, knowledge, abilities, and experience are clearly defined and aligned with the positions of the Board of Directors, subcommittees, and the Executive Committee. The charters of the subcommittees are regularly reviewed and updated to ensure relevance and alignment with their roles, missions, and business operations in the current changing environment, emphasizing balance, prudence, and agility in operations to prepare for changes and business expansion.
1.4 Committed to motivating, developing, and retaining competent personnel. The company places importance on personnel development and retention by providing training and development plans for each position to enhance the knowledge and abilities necessary for job duties and responsibilities, or in changing circumstances. There are annual training plans for each position, both in terms of Hard Skills and Soft Skills. The company also encourages employees to learn through online training and seminar-style learning, promoting knowledge in both theoretical and real-world case studies. Additionally, workshops are organized to allow employees to learn and engage in activities together. Succession planning is in place to ensure continuity and competency in key positions within the organization and to support employee career growth, creating success and pride in the organization for employees. There is also a clear performance evaluation process and fair compensation to motivate and retain employees.
1.5 The company requires personnel in all positions to be responsible for internal control to achieve the objectives. The organizational structure is established, and authority, duties, and responsibilities are defined for each position to ensure that everyone is responsible for the internal control system. Risk management plans are developed for all operational activities, and performance reports are submitted to the Management Meeting, the Enterprise Risk Management Committee, and the Audit Committee. The company also operates under the ISO 9001:2015 quality management system and conducts performance evaluations.
Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control
Yes
Auditor's Observations
The Company agrees with the auditor's opinion that the Company's internal control system is adequate and appropriate for the Company's business operations and can protect the Company's assets from unauthorized or misused use by management. The Audit Committee reported on the adequacy of the Company's internal control system at the Board of Directors meeting.
Internal Audit
The internal audit unit is independent in auditing and assessing the adequacy of the internal control system, including monitoring the improvement of work processes to be appropriate. It covers the work processes of the Company and its subsidiaries, reporting directly to the Audit Committee to ensure that the Company's operations have an adequate, appropriate, and effective internal control system coupled with risk management at a level acceptable to the Company to achieve its operational objectives. The Code of Ethics for Internal Auditors serves as a clear guideline for practice.
The internal audit unit adheres to the ethical guidelines for internal audit practice and operates in accordance with the International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing. The internal audit unit prepares a flexible annual internal audit plan by assessing the strategic business direction and key risks affecting the Company's operations, including the concerns of the Board of Directors and management. The annual internal audit plan will be reviewed and approved by the Audit Committee. In addition to performing work according to the approved audit plan, the internal audit unit also performs other special tasks as requested by management and the Audit Committee as appropriate.
Moreover, according to the annual internal audit plan, the internal audit unit will consider and review potential risks, examine the adequacy and effectiveness of internal control, and report significant internal control deficiencies, non-compliance with regulations, and guidelines for improving work processes to the management. The internal audit unit continuously monitors to ensure that corrective actions are taken according to the recommendations of the internal audit unit, other external auditors, and the resolutions of the Audit Committee. The Audit Committee will be regularly informed of the audit results, including the progress of the management's corrective actions and the progress of the internal audit unit's work, at least once a quarter.
The internal audit unit participates in the investigation of possible fraud and corruption within the Company and reports the results to management and the Audit Committee.
Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
Head of Internal Audit
3160
Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
The Committee is of the opinion that the Company's internal control system is adequate and appropriate. The Company has hired Reanda Multiplus (Thailand) Co., Ltd., an outsource company, and has an internal audit department to coordinate the system effectively. The Company also improves the internal control system of the Company and its subsidiaries in accordance with the recommendations of the independent auditor and presents it to the Audit Committee meeting. In addition, there is an internal control system to monitor and supervise the operations of subsidiaries to prevent the Company's and subsidiaries' assets from being misused or unauthorized by directors or management, including transactions with potentially conflicting or related parties. The Committee is also of the opinion that the Company has adequate internal controls over other matters.
Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit
Requires Audit Committee Approval
Yes
Description
At the Audit Committee Meeting No. 4/2021 held on November 12, 2021, Reanda Multiplus (Thailand) Co., Ltd. was appointed as the Company's internal auditor, effective from January 1, 2022. The Company has assigned Mr. Surapol Thalayavijit to be primarily responsible for performing the duties of the Company's internal auditor.
The Audit Committee has considered the qualifications and appointed Mr. Surapol Thalayavijit as the Head of Internal Audit due to his independence and experience in internal audit work in businesses similar to the Company and his qualifications are sufficient for performing the duties.
For the Company's internal audit, Ms. Saranyathinee Mongkolrat has been appointed as the Company's internal auditor to coordinate with external independent auditors at the Audit Committee Meeting No. 2/2021 held on May 14, 2021.
The consideration and approval of the appointment, removal, and transfer of the Company's internal auditor must be approved by the Audit Committee. The qualifications of the internal auditor are shown in Appendix 3.
Related Party Transactions
Has Related Party Transactions
Yes
Counterparties & Transactions
Monetary Unit
1
Counterparties with Potential Conflicts
| Name | Person / Juristic Person | Type of Business | Nature of Relationship | As of Date (YYYY-MM-DD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VIV Interchem Company Limited | Juristic Person | Chemicals trading and manufacturing | V.I.V. Interchem Co., Ltd. holds 20.92% of the company's shares and has joint directors, namely Mr. Suchart Jiwaportip and Mr. Chanchai Asavakarn. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Divers Chemicals Co., Ltd. | Juristic Person | Wholesale/Retail Trade, Chemical Products, Industrial Chemical Distribution | There are joint directors, namely Mr. Rut Thongwanich and Mr. Rut's family, including his daughter and son-in-law, who hold 3.89% of the company's shares. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Sally Industry Public Company Limited | Juristic Person | Manufacturing of plastic parts, tools, appliances, and other plastic products | Saree Industry Public Company Limited holds 6.79% of the company's shares and has joint directors, namely Mr. Suchart Chivaprapatip and Mr. Chanchai Asavakachan. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Sally Printing Public Company Limited | Juristic Person | Manufacturing and distribution of stickers, labels, and packaging labels | Saree Printing Public Company Limited holds 65% of the company's shares and has a mutual director, Mr. Suchart Jiwaportip. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
| Petchsiam (Thailand) Co., Ltd. | Juristic Person | Other plastic product manufacturing, Manufacturing of other plastic products | Petch Siam (Thailand) Public Company Limited holds 75.5% of the company's shares. | 2024-12-31T00:00 |
Transactions by Counterparty
| Transactions |
|---|
| 11040000.0 · Necessity: • The Company sold goods and raw materials to VIV as per lists 1 and 3, with terms and conditions in line with normal business practices when compared to transactions with other unrelated parties. • Cost plus an average markup of 5% to 10%. Audit Committee's opinion: • The aforementioned transactions are beneficial to the Company's operations. • They are reasonable and conducted under normal commercial terms. · Description: As the aforementioned company is engaged in the import and distribution of chemicals, there may be intercompany transactions such as the purchase and sale of goods and raw materials. These transactions are conducted in the ordinary course of business or in support of the company's normal business operations. · As of yesteryear: 6280000.0 · Nature of transaction: 1. Sales of goods and services 2. Purchases 3. Trade receivables 4. Trade payables 5. Consulting income · Audit committee opinion: Transactions are conducted at arm's length with fair prices and conditions, ensuring no undue advantage is given compared to transactions between the company and the general public, transactions between individuals with conflicts of interest and the general public, or similar transactions conducted by other operators in the industry. |
| 90720000.0 · Necessity: • The Company sells masterbatches and raw materials to DIV as listed in items 1 and 3, which are considered ordinary sales transactions. As DIV operates in the chemical distribution business, they regularly purchase goods from the Company for resale. The terms of trade and pricing are in line with normal business practices when compared to transactions with other unrelated external parties. For goods that cannot be compared to those of external parties, the pricing is determined using a cost-plus markup method in accordance with the established policy. • The Company purchases raw materials from DIV, as listed in items 2 and 4, for use in its regular production processes. DIV, operating in the chemical distribution business, is the sole distributor of these chemicals in Thailand. The terms of trade and pricing are consistent with normal business practices when compared to transactions with other unrelated external parties. Audit Committee Opinion: • The aforementioned transactions are beneficial to the Company's operations. • They are reasonable and conducted under normal commercial terms. · Description: As the company is engaged in the import and distribution of chemicals, there may be intercompany transactions such as the purchase and sale of raw materials or products. These transactions are conducted in the ordinary course of business or in support of the company's normal business operations. · As of yesteryear: 51310000.0 · Nature of transaction: 1. Sales 2. Purchases 3. Accounts Receivable 4. Accounts Payable 5. Purchase of Supplies · Audit committee opinion: Transactions are conducted at arm's length with fair prices and conditions, ensuring no undue advantage is given compared to transactions between the company and the general public, transactions between individuals with conflicts of interest and the general public, or similar transactions conducted by other operators in the industry. |
| 20000.0 · Necessity: • The Company sold raw materials to SALEE as per items 1 and 3. The terms of trade and prices were in accordance with normal business practices when compared to transactions with other unrelated parties. • The Company purchased raw materials from SALEE as per item 2, and the price was in accordance with normal business practices when compared to transactions with other unrelated parties. Audit Committee Opinion • The aforementioned transactions were beneficial to the Company's operations. • They were reasonable and conducted under normal commercial terms. · Description: As the aforementioned company manufactures plastic parts and packaging for the electronics and electrical appliances industries, there may be intercompany transactions such as the purchase and sale of goods, raw materials, or manufacturing services. These transactions are conducted in the ordinary course of business or in support of the company's normal business operations. · As of yesteryear: 12300000.0 · Nature of transaction: 1. Sales 2. Purchases 3. Accounts Receivable 4. Accounts Payable · Audit committee opinion: The listing must have commercial terms and conditions with fair prices and conditions, and must not result in a transfer of benefits when compared to transactions between the company and the general public, or transactions between persons with conflicts of interest with the general public, or similar transactions of other operators in the business. |
| 500000.0 · Necessity: The Company purchased goods from "SLP" as listed in Item 2. The terms of trade and prices are in accordance with normal business practices. The Company purchased the goods for use in the production of its products and the prices are in line with normal trade practices when compared to transactions with other unrelated third parties. · Description: As the company is engaged in the manufacturing and distribution of product labels, there may be intercompany transactions such as the purchase of raw materials. These transactions are conducted in the ordinary course of business or in support of the company's normal business operations. · As of yesteryear: 25440000.0 · Nature of transaction: 1. Sales 2. Purchases 3. Accounts Receivable 4. Accounts Payable · Audit committee opinion: Transactions are conducted at arm's length with fair prices and conditions, ensuring no undue advantage is given compared to transactions between the company and the general public, transactions between parties with conflicts of interest and the general public, or similar transactions conducted by other operators in the industry. |
| 1850000.0 · Necessity: • The Company sold masterbatches to Petch Siam Co., Ltd., as detailed in Item 1 and Item 3, with the terms of trade and pricing consistent with normal business practices when compared to transactions with other unrelated external parties. · Description: As the aforementioned company engages in the manufacturing of processed plastic, there might be intercompany transactions, such as the sale of raw materials. These transactions are considered normal business operations or in support of the company's regular business activities. · As of yesteryear: 1610000.0 · Nature of transaction: 1. Sales 2. Purchases 3. Accounts Receivable 4. Accounts Payable · Audit committee opinion: Transactions are conducted under arm's length trading terms, with fair prices and conditions, ensuring no undue advantage is given when compared to transactions between the company and the public, transactions between individuals with conflicts of interest and the public, or similar transactions conducted by other operators within the industry. |
Policy & Future Trends
Policy, Measures & Approval Process
Currently, the company has established measures and procedures for approving related party transactions. These measures stipulate that executives or interested parties are prohibited from participating in the approval process of such transactions. Additionally, the company has appointed an audit committee to review related party transactions requiring the board of directors' consideration. The board of directors is responsible for ensuring the company's compliance with the regulations set by the Securities and Exchange Commission, as well as the rules, announcements, orders, or requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including regulations concerning the disclosure of related party transactions and the acquisition or disposal of assets by the company and its subsidiaries. The audit committee is responsible for providing opinions on the necessity of entering into transactions and the appropriateness of the transaction price. All related party transactions are conducted fairly, at market prices, and in accordance with normal business practices (Fair and at arm's length), with price comparisons made to those of external parties.
Future Trends in Related Party Transactions
If the Company is required to enter into a transaction with a person who may have a conflict of interest, the Company has a policy to have the Audit Committee provide an opinion on the necessity and appropriateness of such transaction. In the event that the Audit Committee does not have the expertise to consider the intercompany transactions that may arise, the Company will have an independent expert or the Audit Committee provide an opinion on such intercompany transactions for the consideration of the Board of Directors or shareholders, as the case may be.
The Company's policy on intercompany transactions is as follows:
• Normal course of business transactions and transactions supporting the normal course of business, such as the purchase and sale of goods, manufacturing contracts, etc. The Company has a policy for the Audit Committee to consider and provide opinions on the reasons for and necessity of such transactions and that the terms of trade have fair prices and conditions and do not result in the transfer of benefits when compared to transactions between the Company and the general public or transactions between persons who may have a conflict of interest with the general public or transactions of a similar nature to those of other operators in the business. The Company has a policy for the Audit Committee to consider and provide opinions on the reasons for and necessity of such transactions on a quarterly basis and will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and the rules, announcements, orders, or regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the regulations on the disclosure of connected transactions.
• Normal course of business transactions and transactions supporting the normal course of business, such as the purchase and sale of goods, manufacturing contracts, etc. The Company has a policy for the Audit Committee to consider and provide opinions on the reasons for and necessity of such transactions and that the terms of trade have fair prices and conditions and do not result in the transfer of benefits when compared to transactions between the Company and the general public or transactions between persons who may have a conflict of interest with the general public or transactions of a similar nature to those of other operators in the business. The Company has a policy for the Audit Committee to consider and provide opinions on the reasons for and necessity of such transactions on a quarterly basis and will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and the rules, announcements, orders, or regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the regulations on the disclosure of connected transactions. The details of the product types are as follows:
1. General Commodity Group such as white products, black products, and Filler, which are produced in large quantities and sold to many customers. The pricing will be based on the price comparison with other customers.
2. Made-to-order product group refers to products that are manufactured according to the needs of specific customers and cannot be compared to sales to the general public, which may be a channel for transferring benefits out of the Company or its subsidiaries, or distorting accounting and financial information, which may cause damage to the Company and general shareholders. Therefore, for the clarity and transparency of the operations of the Company and its subsidiaries, the Company would like to establish a policy for determining the selling price to persons with conflicts of interest in the form of a Cost Plus pricing.
The pricing based on gross profit is determined from the Actual Cost prepared by the Company's Accounting and Finance Department. In the event that the actual cost is not in line with the gross profit pricing policy as specified above and the purchase or sale value per item exceeds 20,000 Baht per quarter, the details of such transactions shall be clarified by explaining the reasons to the Audit Committee for their acknowledgement and consideration of the appropriateness of such transactions.
• Other transactions apart from the normal course of business and the above-mentioned transactions supporting the normal course of business, such as transactions relating to other assets or services, or transactions providing or receiving financial assistance. The Company has a policy for the Audit Committee to consider and provide opinions on the reasons for and necessity of such transactions and will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and the rules, announcements, orders, or regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the regulations on the disclosure of connected transactions and the acquisition or disposal of major assets of the Company or its subsidiaries. The Company does not have a policy of lending money to persons who may have a conflict of interest to conduct business or operate on behalf of the Company.
The Board of Directors will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and the rules, announcements, orders, or regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the regulations on connected transactions and the acquisition or disposal of major assets of the Company or its subsidiaries. To ensure that the decision to enter into such transactions does not create a conflict of interest and is in the best interests of all shareholders, the Company will disclose such intercompany transactions in the Annual Information Form (56-1 One Report) and the notes to the financial statements audited by the Company's auditors.
